What unfair dismissal changes mean for probation period rights in the UK

There’s a feeling of unease among British employers, with unfair dismissal reforms on their way in January 2027.

Probation period rights won’t change as such. However, earlier unfair dismissal rights could encourage employers to shorten an employee’s probation period to reduce risk.

We’ll delve into that a little bit later; in the meantime, let’s go over what’s changing.

Changes to unfair dismissal rights in 2027

From January 1 2027, an employee can claim unfair dismissal after six weeks of employment, rather than the current two years. “It’s actually five months and three weeks due to a quirk in the legislation,” said Ethan Diver, solicitor at Taylor Walton Solicitors. In other words, dismissals will  need to take effect at least a week before the six months has passed. Doing this will account for the employee’s rights to statutory minimum notice.

The new rules apply to staff who started employment from July 1, 2026, as January 1 will be the six-month point where they gain unfair dismissal rights.

The cap on compensation for unfair dismissal awards at tribunal will also be removed. So, the award limit for the employee could be, well, limitless.

What this means for employers

In the first instance, the employer might be inclined to panic, which is completely understandable.

Offering fewer fixed term contracts will start to become appealing, especially with contracts that typically exceed five months. It’s important to be realistic about the staff you need, though. Consider periods of growth for the business where you want someone for an extended period, but not permanently.

Another consequence is a strain on the legal system. Employment tribunal backlogs, for one, are likely to get even more agonising than they already are. “Employment tribunal claims are taking considerable time to reach a final hearing, and extending unfair dismissal protection to millions of employees at an earlier stage of employment is likely to increase claim volumes further,” said Vikki Cunliffe, senior associate at Trowers & Hamlins LLP. “For employers, this could mean greater uncertainty, greater financial liability and longer-running disputes.”

Take steps now to make things easier for you when the new laws come into place. “Use the lead-in period to review contracts of employment, probation arrangements, recruitment processes and disciplinary and performance management procedures,” said Cunliffe.

Is a shorter probation period right for your business?

Many small business owners would consider a reduction in their probation period. It could reduce from six months to three or four months, for example. The probation process would need to be airtight, with regular reviews from you and/or from their line manager.

Deciding whether to make the cut

Shortening probation has pros and cons for both the employer and the employee, said Patrick Glencross, employment law solicitor at Parfitt Cresswell Solicitors. His point is that three months may be too short a timescale to judge a new employee’s suitability if they spend much of this time in training. It could also fall short if the nature of their role, such as sales or management, requires a longer period to assess their performance. On the other hand, a shortened probation period may put pressure on the employer to make a premature decision about the employee, and the employer may not want to run the risk of continuing employment if they’re not yet certain. “Making a premature decision in this way could mean losing someone who could well have succeeded in their role with a little more time, additional training or clearer feedback,” he told Small Business.

You might decide that a six-month (or longer) probation is still much more apt for the roles you hire for. Senior and managerial roles which involve more skill naturally warrant a longer probation period.

Just keep a keen eye on those probation start and end dates. “The reduction in the qualifying service period now means that where probation periods exceeding six months are used, the employee could acquire ordinary unfair dismissal protection during their probationary period,” Charlotte Sloan, partner in the employment team at Birketts LLP, said. “The employer would then have to establish a fair reason and conduct a fair process before dismissing.”

Performance problems

So, you can only fairly dismiss said employee on performance grounds where you can demonstrate that their performance is lacking after you carry out a fair procedure, said Diver. “This would ordinarily include providing the employee with structured feedback and support and allowing them the opportunity to improve their performance.”

Fairness is paramount here and would help your case in an employment tribunal. “You should give the employee a chance to respond to concerns and a realistic opportunity to improve, where they consider the employee is not meeting the required standards,” said Glencross.

If issues with performance crop up when the new employee is on the job, you need to address them early. Don’t leave it until the end of probation where you’re at higher risk of slipping past the six-month marker.

Better hiring practices

Just as landlords have had to be more careful with which tenants they take, you’ll need to make sharper hiring decisions. Make sure the role is a clear as can be before you even start interviewing. You can match the candidates closely to the criteria – and to each other. Knowing exactly what you want avoids any wishy-washy hiring choices, too. “Whilst this requires a mindset shift, it may ultimately lead to better hiring decisions and earlier intervention together with reduced risk exposure when issues do arise,” Dean told .

See also: Hiring freelancers vs employees – navigating the legal and financial differences

The potential fallouts of a shorter probation period

It’s worth considering the impact on the employee that a shorter probation period could have. “The pressure and stress may in turn impact adversely on their performance,” said Glencross. However, if you’ve got someone who isn’t the right fit, there’s a chance of it going awry in the opposite way: “It could lead to unsuitable employees, who turn out to be unsuccessful in the long-term, being kept on because they overachieve in the early stages of their employment,” said Diver.

Employee protections that count from day one

These changes are coming about as a result of the Employment Rights Act 2005. Bear in mind that employees now have new day-one protections, too. Employees have:

  • Paternity and unpaid parental leave
  • The right to ask for flexible working

It’s best to be fully clued-up on employment law as something you’re unaware of could easily catch you out. “Employers should remember that probation has never been a risk-free period,” said Ben Calvet-Williams, associate at Orwins. “Claims such as discrimination, whistleblowing and certain automatically unfair dismissal claims can already arise without the qualifying service needed for an ordinary unfair dismissal claim.”

For more one employment law changes, check out these articles.

An essential guide to Statutory Sick Pay for employers – Statutory Sick Pay (SSP) supports businesses by ensuring their employees take the proper time to recover as well as preventing illnesses spreading through the workplace

How to deal with sexual harassment in your small business – Sexual harassment and your small business. What to do if one of your staff members complains about being harassed at work

Original source What unfair dismissal changes mean for probation period rights in the UK

Back to home