
What drives house prices? Wealth, supply, affordability and yields, says Handelsbanken’s James Sproule. Ministers should step back.
All governments tend to be in favour of home ownership, since it provides people with an achievable store of wealth and a demonstrable stake in society – not to mention a roof over one’s head. We also know there has been, over the last century or more, widespread desire to own a home. In 1919, homeowner occupation was 23 per cent, it reached just over 50 per cent in 1980 and peaked at over 70 per cent in the wake of Mrs Thatcher’s program of selling council homes to tenants. It has since wavered, then recovered somewhat, to now stand at 65 percent. So why can no one afford a house? And what can the government do?
The news that over half of the cost of a dwelling in London comes from regulation and tax may shock many outside the M25, though few within. The government is trying to help, but modelling suggests around half of first-time buyers in the South East may not be eligible for the Your First Home scheme. Worse, recent data reveals the ‘New Build Premium’ – the difference in cost between a new-build home and a directly-comparable existing one – is 26 per cent. Since new-builds compete against existing housing stock, those prices act as a natural limiting factor to how much new-builds can charge. Moreover, with build costs exacerbated through additional taxes and rises to the National Living Wage, the government’s promise to “build more” has run up against economic reality. So, it is worth asking: what actually drives house prices?
There are four distinct drivers.
The first is long-term wealth accumulation. People today are far wealthier than their parents were; notwithstanding the current cost-of-living crisis, spending has increased 240 per cent since 1986. All the data shows that when people are richer they spend disproportionately on two things: foreign holidays and housing. This does not dictate house prices year-to-year, but has overall driven them upwards.
Stay in the know
Three daily briefings with the key market moves and top business and political stories.
SUBSCRIBE HEREThe next is supply. Measured against comparable European nations, the UK has amongst the lowest number of dwellings per capita. Our demographic profile is pretty similar to that for France, which has 38m homes against our 31m. Demographic developments may eventually change this, but we currently have a structural housing shortage. Lots of effort – some effective – has been made to change this, but the challenge looks set to persist, and will likewise keep housing reasonably expensive.
Perhaps the best thing this – or any government – could do is leave the market well alone
However, these are not the only factors. The next – and most keenly-watched – aspect is affordability. House prices relative to income rose to an all-time high in the summer of 2022 but, since then, real house values have fallen and earnings risen, each by 10 per cent. This has taken the price-to-earnings ratio back to levels last seen in 2002. So whilst there remains some challenge here the market is correcting back towards normality.
Finally, there is the often-overlooked matter of yields: the rent received as a percentage of capital value. While most people do not value their homes thus, there are enough professional buyers in the market that yields matter. Typically, residential housing delivers a premium around 3.5 per cent above the risk-free rate delivered by Gilts. This compensates landlords for the risks of tenancy voids, investment and general hassle compared to simply owning Gilts. But rises to Gilt yields over the past few years have squeezed that premium to half its normal level. For yields to stabilise means, at best, a prolonged spell of stagnant nominal prices, while inflation slowly adjusts real valuations. As with affordability, this is hopefully good news for first-time buyers.
Overall, then, the market would seem to be balancing. However, markets do not exist in a vacuum. Any government intervention, however well-meaning, has the potential to distort them. At the top end, a Mansion Tax is set to be introduced, although it looks likely the tax liability itself will undermine yields and therefore weaken valuations. At the other end, schemes like Your First Home look set to increase buyer demand without addressing supply – artificially raising values of eligible homes.
The irony is that the market was already correcting – with more efficiency and less bureaucracy than any government scheme. Whatever people think their home is worth, what matters is what buyers can afford; the bid sets the price. As for new builds, developers will not build houses where expenses exceed realistic sale prices, so the more costs added into construction, the fewer homes will be built.
This government, like those before, wants to increase home ownership, and rightly so. But perhaps the best thing it – or any government – could do to achieve this is leave well alone.
James Sproule is chief economist at Handelsbanken