
JD Wetherspoon founder Sir Tim Martin has criticised the UK’s “absurd” governance rules and said he is “hopeful” he will survive a potential shareholder revolt, after an advisory group called for him to be ousted from the pub chain he founded.
Martin, chairman of the pub group, said he hopes all “sensible” shareholders will refuse the advice of an influential shareholder proxy to vote against his reelection at its board meeting on Thursday.
Glass Lewis, a top shareholder advisor, has urged Wetherspoon investors to oust Martin because he attended only six of the firm’s nine board meetings this year, below the 75 per cent threshold it deems necessary.
The advisory group said shareholders “may reasonably view this as a failure to fulfill a fundamental responsibility,” adding that the pub firm has “failed to disclose an explanation for this director’s relatively poor attendance”.
Glass Lewis also questioned whether Martin deserves to remain as the pub firm’s chairman because he has been in post since 1983, far exceeding the “nine-year rule” which generally dictates how long a board member should remain in post.
Stay in the know
Three daily briefings with the key market moves and top business and political stories.
SUBSCRIBE HEREBut the Wetherspoon boss has hit back at this pressure, telling that “many UK corporate governance rules are absurd and counterproductive”. He said the “best companies in the world,” naming Amazon, Berkshire Hathaway and Oracle, do not comply with the nine-year rule.
Martin said he avoids rescheduling board meetings if he cannot attend because it is “disruptive to do so,” adding that it is “good governance” for the board of a company to occasionally meet without its chairman, “who, in spite of the best of intentions, might have excessive influence over the agenda”.
Martin pins hopes on ‘sensible’ shareholders
The pub boss said he expects to stay on as chairman of the pub firm he founded: “Sensible shareholders will look at things in the round.
“Wetherspoon doesn’t overpay, has never been accused of dishonesty and floated at (adjusted for share splits) 32 pence in 1992. So we’re not Microsoft or Amazon, but we’ve worked hard in our small corner.
“I’m hopeful that we get resounding support from shareholders – for the sake of our 42,000 staff, among other reasons.”
Glass Lewis has also urged investors to vote against Wetherspoon’s remuneration policy, which proposes linking bonuses to how long board members have served at the company rather than their performance.
This is not the first time the fund adviser has attracted the ire of Sir Tim, who in 2019 accused the group of “financial illiteracy” after it told investors to vote against the company’s pay deal.
Glass Lewis had raised the alarm of a “significant” hike to the fixed pay of Wetherspoon’s finance chief, which they warned could be used as a “crutch” if they failed to meet performance targets.
Martin told the Sunday Times the advisory’s accusations were “complete bollocks”. He said: “The most toxic and damaging aspect of corporate governance is the obsession with targets. In the pub sector they cause people to underpay staff, not to carry out essential repairs, and to try to artificially enhance profits.”
JD Wetherspoon, which runs 797 pubs in the UK, hailed a “good start to the financial year” earlier this month when it posted a 9.4 per cent increase in bar sales. The group’s shares have gained 39 per cent in the year to date.