UK government loses bid to keep Apple surveillance order secret

Hand interacting with a white foldable Apple iPhone, showing its dual cameras and partially folded screen

The UK government has lost a bid to keep its Apple surveillance order a secret, after a tribunal ruled against the Home Office’s efforts not to confirm or deny a notice it issued to the iPhone maker that would have forced it to share encrypted data.

The claim follows the Home Office’s argument that publicly confirming or denying whether it had issued a so-called technical capability notice (TCN) to Apple would damage national security.

The tribunal rejected this, finding the Home Office’s national security assessment “flawed in the public law sense”. As the notice’s existence is already widely known, and easily retrieved via a simple Google chatbot query, the tribunal said confirming it in court poses no new risk to national security.

While the existence of the TCN is now public, its specific technical details remain secret.

The tech giant had launched its second legal action against the government at the Investigatory Powers Tribunal after the media reported that the Home Office had issued another notice seeking access to its encrypted data. This came less than a year after Whitehall withdrew an earlier order against Apple after a diplomatic spat with Washington.

Stay in the know

Three daily briefings with the key market moves and top business and political stories.

SUBSCRIBE HERE

The government’s notice was served under the UK’s Investigatory Powers Act (IPA), dubbed the ‘snooper’s charter’, which allows the Home Secretary to issue technical capability notices and force tech companies to provide access to encrypted data.

The iPhone maker refused to build a backdoor, arguing that weakening encryption for UK users compromises its global security. The tech giant also removed its advanced data protection (ADP) feature from the UK due to a dispute with the government.

In August, Apple filed its legal challenge to the tribunal that specialises in surveillance complaints. The hearing was held on 17 September.

On Thursday, the tribunal slammed “authorised leaks” to The Times and The Financial Times confirming the order, stating they fatally undermined the government’s argument that official confirmation would harm national security.

Home Office witnesses claimed leak investigations into the media articles found no government source, yet the tribunal said it failed to provide any investigation reports, details of the steps taken, or witness statements from Ministers denying they authorised the briefings.

Main trial to proceed in 2027

Apple’s legal challenge to the surveillance powers, alongside a parallel challenge by Privacy International and Liberty, will proceed to a substantive hearing in the first half of 2027, with much of it now open to the public.

This is not the first time the parties were in court over this issue. Apple launched a legal challenge against the Home Office at the tribunal after its first notice last year.

The case was expected to be heard early this year after the tribunal initially refused the Home Secretary’s request to hold it in secret without any public listing. It was abandoned after diplomatic pushback from Washington, which led the Home Office to withdraw the global order.

Today’s judgment also detailed how the UK government authorised Apple to brief the US Vice President and Attorney General while gagging them from briefing Congress, and cites public claims by former US Representative Tulsi Gabbard that the UK briefly backed down before issuing a fresh order.

Apple and the Home Office have been contacted for comment.

Original source UK government loses bid to keep Apple surveillance order secret

Back to home