Top law firm faces court dispute over $11.5m sanctions freeze

Royal Courts of Justice facade, representing BHPs failed appeal in Brazil dam disaster case under environmental law

Global law firm Reed Smith is facing a two week trial brought against it by two shipping companies to claw back $11.5m (£8.7m) in frozen funds following a collapsed ship sale.

The Pennsylvania-headquartered firm, which has a large office in London, is defending itself in the High Court against the claim brought by shipping companies, Virgo Marine and Nixie Marine.

The shipping firms allege Reed Smith, who acted for ship seller, Kibaz Shipping LP, and as an escrow agent – a neutral third party – wrongly instructed Barclays to block the money following Virgo Marine being placed under US sanctions in 2022.

Reed Smith instructed Barclays to block the funds because they claimed to be a ‘US person’ for sanctions purposes, despite being a UK registered LLP, an error which Reed Smith later acknowledged.

In 2022, the Ultimate Beneficial Owner (UBO) of Nixie Marine wished to purchase a ship and enlisted assistance from Virgo, which instructed brokers and identified the ship sold by Kibaz Shipping LP.

Stay in the know

Three daily briefings with the key market moves and top business and political stories.

SUBSCRIBE HERE

However, when Dubai-based firm Virgo was placed under sanction by the US Office of Foreign Assets Control (OFAC) in September 2022, the purchase of the ship fell through, with the money for the purchase remaining in Reed Smith’s client account.

Reed Smith “seems to have panicked”

The shipping firms’ legal team, represented by Quillon Law, said in its skeleton argument Reed Smith “seems to have panicked” and “made the crucial error which has given rise to the present litigation”, referring to the freezing decision.

The claim also alleges Reed Smith’s assessment was “contrary to its self-professed expertise in sanctions matters”.

Both parties agree the money is owed to one or both shipping companies, whose lawyers, in their argument, said Reed Smith “should be ordered to pay the relevant sums to the Claimants’ solicitors by whatever means are available.”

“For around 4 years, we have been in dispute with Reed Smith. That is despite the fact that Reed Smith accept they are in a debtor and creditor relationship with one or both of Virgo and Nixie, a spokesperson said on behalf of the shipping firms.

“Reed Smith hold themselves out as being experts in sanctions law yet applied the law incorrectly to their own position,” they said.

The spokesperson added the consequences of Reed Smith wrongly designating themselves as a US person “have led not only to the escrow monies not being returned, but to years of litigation – during which Reed Smith sought to blame Barclays and even Virgo and Nixie – which Virgo and Nixie hope will now come to a swift end.”

Reed Smith, which is disputing the allegations, said in its argument the shipping companies are advancing a “scattergun array of alternative claims and allegations in an effort to make RS (Reed Smith) answer for Barclays’ default” over the frozen funds.

In a statement, the law firm said it “strongly disputes the allegations and maintains that this claim should never have been brought and is without merit.”

“We are confident that we acted appropriately in accordance with our legal and professional obligations and we will be inviting the Court to dismiss the claim in its entirety,” Reed Smith said.

The trial began on 17 November and oral closing submissions are expected on 1 December.

Barclays was contacted for comment.

Original source Top law firm faces court dispute over $11.5m sanctions freeze

Back to home