
The medicines we rely on, the clothes we wear, the smartphones we carry and much of the infrastructure that powers the green transition all depend on hydrocarbon sources like Rosebank, writes Sharon Todd
While politicians, lobbying organisations and pressure groups debate and argue about whether the Rosebank oil field should be given the go-ahead, a vital part of the discussion is being overlooked.
The argument for continuing use of hydrocarbons is not simply about how we heat our homes or fuel our cars. It is about safeguarding the most critical raw material which is vital in the production of many everyday items which underpin modern life.
We should absolutely support the move to renewable energy but long after Britain has electrified much of its transport system and decarbonised large parts of its power sector, it will still depend on hydrocarbons for thousands of products that society simply cannot function without.
A year ago, SCI and the National Preparedness Commission produced a report, Industrial Resilience: Assessing the foundations of UK industry, which stressed the grave consequences for the UK’s resilience, security and prosperity should we forget that hydrocarbons remain critical not only for energy security but also as feedstocks for the overwhelming majority of industrial materials used across modern economies.
Stay in the know
Three daily briefings with the key market moves and top business and political stories.
SUBSCRIBE HEREHowever, this inconvenient fact receives remarkably little attention in political debate, despite the growing focus on resilience and preparedness.
Hydrocarbons are critical raw materials
Most people understand that oil and gas generate heat and power. Far fewer realise that they are the critical raw materials for medical equipment, medicines, plastics, clothes, detergents, packaging, electronics, paints, adhesives, fertilisers and countless other products used every day. Our report warned policymakers not to equate the transition to a low-carbon economy with the end of hydrocarbon production: it warned that this view is fundamentally flawed.
Healthcare is a good example of this. Many pharmaceutical ingredients are derived from hydrocarbons. Syringes, protective equipment, IV bags and medical devices also all depend on materials produced from fossil carbon. The same is true of agriculture, which relies on fertilisers derived from hydrocarbon feedstock inputs. Even the many technologies promoted as part of the green transition, including batteries, wind turbines and solar panels, depend upon sophisticated carbon supply chains whose foundations ultimately trace back to hydrocarbon feedstocks.
Whilst other routes to making these materials based on different sources of carbon are in development, the reality is that there is currently no alternative capable of replacing fossil fuel-based feedstocks at the scale required by modern life. Alternative pathways should and are being pursued but they remain limited by cost, scale and practicality, meaning hydrocarbons will remain essential for materials production well into the foreseeable future.
This reality should shape our thinking about the natural assets that the UK has.
Rosebank isn’t incompatible with climate goals
Critics often argue that approving new North Sea developments is incompatible with Britain’s climate ambitions, but this is not always correct. Seeking to eliminate local production of oil and gas does not eliminate our consumption of products made from hydrocarbons. If these products are not available domestically, they will be imported from elsewhere often produced with a significantly higher carbon footprint and then transported over long distances. Carbon Brief noted that the CO2 emissions in China from chemical production increased by 12 per cent in 2025. Most people may be shocked to think that we may be relying on coal derived products which come with a significantly worse carbon footprint. A nation serious about decarbonisation and resilience should not willingly accelerate its dependence on imports thinking this is improving the UK’s carbon footprint. The opposite is the reality. That is not environmental leadership.
The pandemic, the war in Ukraine and ongoing geopolitical tensions in the Middle East have demonstrated how fragile global supply chains can become. In a major disruption to trade, many of the products and industrial capabilities upon which modern Britain depends quickly come under strain.
Energy security is just one part of the picture
Energy security is rightly part of the discussion. But industrial security matters just as much. The sensible course is to pursue both objectives simultaneously: continue reducing emissions through innovation and cleaner technologies while maintaining secure domestic manufacture of the products upon which we depend.
That means accepting a simple reality. We rely on carbon for most everyday products, and the road to net zero does rely on materials derived from hydrocarbons. The medicines we rely on, the clothes we wear, the smartphones we carry and much of the infrastructure that powers the green transition all depend on this critical carbon source.
The decision on whether to allow drilling in the Rosebank oil field is not a simple black and white choice between the future and the past. It is a symbol of how decisions will be made and these key decisions need to be informed by science as well as economics.
For a country that claims to value energy security, industrial resilience, decarbonisation and strategic independence, that should not be a difficult decision.
is chief executive officer at SCI (Formerly Society of Chemical Industry)