‘The mid-terms will be good for US stocks’

The 5 November US stocks sell-off made commentators jump to the conclusion that “the AI bubble had burst” and that a Democrat Congress would be bad for investors. Of course, it's far too soon to judge, but the evidence points in the opposite direction – that markets are likely to perform strongly well into next year and perhaps beyond.

This would not be a surprise given past experience. Politicians may not like the state of gridlock that occurs when the majority party in Congress is different from the president, but markets love it – it maintains the checks and balances that are an integral part of the US system. Consequently, the US market has not, as the stock market historian Ken Fisher points out, had a negative return between the end of the third quarter in mid-term election year and the middle of the following year since the 1930s. The average return has been 20%. Since 1950, the average return in the 12 months following the mid-terms is 15%, says JPMorgan. But, maybe, this time it's different?

US stocks are not particularly expensive

On election day, the S&P 500 was trading on a prospective multiple of around 18 times earnings. This is not especially expensive by historic standards, particularly with the yield on the ten-year Treasury bond a little below 5%. Third-quarter earnings were up 26% year on year and 30% is expected for the fourth quarter. After 35% earnings growth in 2026, a further 16% is expected in both 2027 and 2028. That would put the S&P at its current level on 15.4 times prospective earnings at the end of 2027.

Start your trial of MoneyWeek today

Get unparalleled financial insight, analysis and expert opinion you can profit from.

Start your trial

Sign up for MoneyWeek’s free twice-daily newsletter.

Join more than 165,000 subscribers and keep yourself informed with latest financial news, insights and expert analysis to help you understand what really matters when it comes to your finances.

Join more than 165,000 subscribers and keep yourself informed with latest financial news, insights and expert analysis to help you understand what really matters when it comes to your finances.

Earnings outside the US have, overall, tracked sideways since 2008, but picked up strongly in 2026, helped by the phenomenal growth at the three Asian heavyweights Samsung, SK Hynix and Taiwan Semiconductor. The prospective multiple on the MSCI All Country World ex-US index, according to Ed Yardeni, is 12, with a range of 14.7 for Japan to 8.6 for emerging markets. If the US is inexpensive, the rest of the world is cheap.

The S&P index, up 12% in the year to date, was not overbought on election day, having traded broadly sideways since June. However, that performance was pretty good for a mid-term year, usually the most difficult part of the electoral cycle. Investors' sentiment surveys were far from euphoric or complacent. There is no reason why this time it should be an exception to past precedents.

Will there be a clamp down on tech?

But surely the Democrats want to restrict the technology sector in general and the AI sector in particular? Isn't that why the information technology sector fell 7% in one day? Newly elected Democratic governors, notably in Texas, want to slow or stop the frenetic construction of data centres in their states. But Gina Hinojosa, the new governor of Texas, which accounts for 30% of the planned projects, has said that “all currently permitted data centres in Texas will be allowed to finish construction”. This covers projects scheduled for 2027 and 2028.

On the face of it, restrictions on data centres might seem to throw a spanner in the works for the longer-term expansion of AI. But investors have been getting increasingly worried about the frenetic roll-out of data centres, the threat of excess capacity and the strain that financing puts on capital markets. Restricting the medium-term growth removes that threat and favours the incumbents, resulting in better profits and cash flow. This may seem negative in the short term, but should be bullish thereafter for the big tech companies.

The reduction in the potential strain of data-centre financing on capital markets has already helped the bond market to rally, reducing yields. This should be of benefit to the wider economy, especially the housing market. Also helpful has been the drop in the oil price, to $90 a barrel for West Texas and $98 for Brent as traders assume that a resolution of the Gulf War is now more likely. This may be painted as a triumph for Iran, but Iran has suffered terribly from the war in economic terms. Its dream of being a regional superpower, spreading discord, war and terrorism throughout the Middle East, is in tatters and its relations with its Gulf neighbours are probably irreparable.

Lower oil prices will mean lower inflation both directly and indirectly through second-round effects. Interest rates will rise in December, but that should be followed by lower rates next year, to the benefit of economic growth and corporate profits. The risk that the AI boom will be followed by a bust is surely reduced by a more moderate pace of expansion. In time, the data centres will still be built, but improved technology should reduce their size and cost and increase their energy efficiency. This will help, not hinder the technology sector.

A less-noticed election before the mid-terms

Another, much less noticed, election took place shortly before the mid-terms – the provincial election in British Columbia. The emphatic win of the Conservatives over the NDP social democrats should pave the way for the construction of an oil pipeline from Alberta to the Pacific and export facilities there and the exploitation of gas reserves in the province. Canada has had to sell its oil at a knock-down price, $25 a barrel below world prices, to America because its supply is landlocked; this should open an export route and encourage additional production. It would raise the price of oil in America, thereby discouraging adventurism overseas, and help lower it internationally.

Yet again, a one-day market setback has created a pessimistic narrative and, probably, knocked investors' sentiment. For contrarians, this is excellent news and paves the way for further market gains.

This article was first published in MoneyWeek's magazine. Enjoy exclusive early access to news, opinion and analysis from our team of financial experts with a MoneyWeek subscription.

Original source ‘The mid-terms will be good for US stocks’

Back to home