The Guardian view on Britain and Europe: Burnham’s reset cannot be the final destination | Editorial

ndy Burnham on Friday announced a long-awaited deal to ease some of Brexit's barriers. But EU sources say the agreements, or at least some of them, won't take effect until Britain has resolved a dispute over its demand for European students to pay the same university tuition fees as British ones. The prime minister had hoped to turn the page on Brexit's endless haggling. Instead, he was reminded that closer ties come at a price. This does not negate his achievement. The deals ease trade barriers on food, shield British exporters from EU carbon tariffs and let up to 100,000 young people on each side live and work across the Channel for three years. But Mr Burnham cannot claim an unqualified diplomatic victory.

Nigel Farage.

Clearly, such an advance would have been unimaginable under the Conservatives or Reform. The Tories say they will rip up the agreements, though that stance carries the risk of alienating voters lost to the Liberal Democrats in 2024. Nigel Farage admits that Brexit was botched. But he wants greater divergence from, rather than increased closeness to, Europe. Both rightwing parties face a dilemma: how to oppose the better relationship when even Mr Farage acknowledges its benefits?

Mr Burnham is on to something: polls consistently show that many voters think that Brexit has not worked out well and rejoining the bloc has gained popularity. The rise of the European radical right also probably changes the EU's calculation about Britain. Building closer ties with a broadly pro-European British government could mean the terms of future agreements allow for Britain's preferential access to the bloc. However, Brussels won't offer something for nothing. As the Swiss ambassador to the UK told a Lords committee earlier this year: "If you want to have access to the common market, you will need to pay some cohesion money."

Horse-trading is a feature of geopolitical life for Brexit Britain. The EU is using public borrowing and procurement rules to encourage defence production within Europe, create economies of scale and strengthen European supply chains. Britain balked at the financial contrib
ution
Brussels wanted in order to join up. With British defence manufacturers in danger of losing access to an expanding European market, both sides have made noises about getting around the table – but so far a deal remains elusive.

Brussels' "Made in Europe" industrial strategy poses another challenge. Britain imports cheap Chinese electric vehicles while the EU seeks to protect its producers. British carmakers, however, depend on European demand. Under proposals advanced before this meeting they risked being shut out of the market. The summit recognised this danger, promising closer cooperation on electric vehicle supply chains. But that may require Britain to align its policies with Brussels – without having a vote over them.

This week Labour's Stella Creasy, and Bernd Lange, a senior German MEP, proposed a Swiss-style deal to restore Britain's economic and diplomatic influence without rejoining the EU. But greater market access without membership means accepting rules that Britain cannot influence. Mr Burnham's reset pursued selective agreements – allowing Brussels to press for concessions. Switzerland offers a warning: frustrated by more than 120 bilateral deals, the EU insisted on a new framework. Down the line, Britain could face the same dilemma. Mr Burnham must calculate how long the country can negotiate the benefits of membership without confronting the costs of staying outside.

Original source The Guardian view on Britain and Europe: Burnham’s reset cannot be the final destination | Editorial

Back to home