
Getting to the bottom of things is part of the job of a litigation lawyer. The same can be said for police officers, investigative journalists and even doctors in search of a diagnosis. A question being posed Down Under is whether it is also part of the job for Cricket Australia.
In 2018, during a Test match between South Africa and Australia in Cape Town, the Australian fielder Cameron Bancroft was caught by TV cameras applying sandpaper to roughen up one side of the ball so it would move more in the air. This was cheating.
Cricket Australia conducted an immediate investigation and relatively quickly singled out three players for punishment. Bancroft, the captain Steve Smith and vice-captain David Warner (all batsmen) were banned for between nine months and a year.
However, questions remained. Why were no bowlers found to have been involved? It was the bowlers who would exploit the altered condition of the ball.
In 2021, following some unwelcome media coverage, the bowling group issued a denial around the use of sandpaper on the field of play.
Stay in the know
Three daily briefings with the key market moves and top business and political stories.
SUBSCRIBE HERENow Usman Khawaja says the whole team knew about the scheme. Bancroft says he deliberately withheld evidence of the team’s wider knowledge from the original investigation. Chadd Sayers, a fast bowler, says he took sandpaper off the field during the previous Test at Port Elizabeth and was never interviewed as part of the original investigation.
Pat Cummins, now Australia’s captain, continues to deny knowing about the scheme.
Cricket Australia today is run by different people, who were not involved in the previous investigation. Failing to re-examine what happened runs a serious risk of digging an even deeper hole.
Cricket Australia has proposed a “forum” where players and staff can come forward to give their accounts of what happened. This, however, is a mistake.
While led by an independent lawyer, it is voluntary and confidential. There has even been a suggestion that different versions of the truth may be contemplated.
Why a new Sandpapergate inquiry is unavoidable
What Cricket Australia should do is set up a fresh, truly independent inquiry. Such a process would start by looking at how the original investigation was run and what it was trying to achieve.
Who was interviewed? Who was left out and why? What documents were called for, what was handed over and what has been preserved? The investigators should have access to the original interview records and match footage, and their remit should cover both Tests.
It is surely important to establish why Bancroft chose to hold back information (if indeed he did), whether he was encouraged to do so and, if so, by whom. If the wider group did know about the sandpaper, did the three players who were singled out take a disproportionate share of the blame?
The investigators should test the reliability of the evidence, give those they propose to criticise a fair chance to respond and publish reasoned findings. The findings may be painful for Cricket Australia, but it is essential for the integrity of the organisation going forward that they should be aired.
Indeed, by failing to do this, Cricket Australia risks an external intervention which could be far more uncomfortable.
If this were happening in England and the same scandal was engulfing the England and Wales Cricket Board, I suspect there might be calls for parliamentary intervention. The House of Commons could require the attendance of witnesses and the production of documents – and it may not be long before an Australian senator triggers a move for an inquiry of a similar sort.
One thing is clear: if Cricket Australia does not grip Sandpapergate now, it will forever be a blight on both its game and its administration.
Simon Bushell is senior partner at Seladore Legal and has extensive experience in complex cross-border disputes and investigations.