
Dealmaking within the UK’s hugely competitive retail sector is back on the agenda, as high street businesses vie to coax cash out of shoppers’ increasingly tight wallets.
Rising business costs, shaky consumer confidence and a less aggressive competition watchdog mean retailers are now looking again at the prospect of consolidation, analysts and advisors told .
Last month, reports that supermarket giant Sainsbury’s had held merger talks with Morrisons, its smaller rival, rocked the grocery sector, disrupting a years-long period of calm within the market.
No deal approaching this scale had been attempted since the Competition and Markets Authority (CMA) blocked Sainsbury’s attempted takeover of budget chain Asda in 2019 over fears it would push up prices for shoppers.
Though talks between Sainsbury’s and Morrisons ended in February, it is understood that they could resume at a later date. It has long been speculated within the industry that one of either Morrisons or Asda could be the subject of a takeover, as both struggle to gain market share and grapple with multi-billion-pound debt piles.
Stay in the know
Three daily briefings with the key market moves and top business and political stories.
SUBSCRIBE HEREAs Tesco rides high at the top of the grocery sector, with a 27.8 per cent market share, its counterparts in the UK’s “big four” – Sainsbury’s, Morrisons and Asda – face a tall order in catching up.
Asda looks to have been shocked into action by rumours of a tie-up between two of its biggest rivals. Since the arrival of new chief executive David Potts, the discount grocer has been looking at potential takeover targets, the Financial Times has reported.
Rivals hope to chase Tesco
Rather than being the subject of a swoop, Asda is reportedly weighing up whether it should swoop for a company in an “adjacent” market. These could include discount retailers B&M, The Range or Home Bargains, people told the newspaper.
Retail analysts and advisors told that Asda, which saw its market share slip from 11.6 to 11.3 per cent in the 12 weeks to November, could be hoping to acquire more customers through a takeover of one of these businesses. It would also hope to find savings in its supply chain if it gained control of another retailer.
Josh Holmes, head of research at Retail Economics, said: “You can see why dealmaking is back on the agenda. Costs have risen, growth is hard won and there’s only so much retailers can pass on when shoppers are watching every pound.
“A bigger business can negotiate better terms with suppliers and spread the cost of things like distribution and technology.”
But Holmes questioned whether Asda is ready for a big-ticket takeover, as its new boss Potts conceded last week that the grocer has neglected its stores in recent years.
“We’re making it harder than it should be for customers to get what they want, move around the store and pay for their shopping. We need to change that, starting now,” he told staff on his first day as chief executive.
While an increasingly tight market may be pushing retailers to consider deals, all proposed takeovers would have to get past the CMA. The watchdog has not been afraid to slap down high-profile deals in the past, including the Sainsbury’s-Asda tie-up.
But the CMA has not rejected a deal in some time, and retail industry figures have suggested that the recent emergence of Aldi and Lidl as prominent players in the grocery market has soothed concerns that the sector lacks competition.
Dominic Ross, an M&A partner at Clifford Chance, said a less combative CMA is the “most important” factor behind the rising prospect of dealmaking in the sector.
“At the start of the decade, the CMA were blocking quite a few deals. Since the chair changed, it’s clear that the Labour government’s emphasis on being more pro-growth, creating a more favourable environment for dealmaking, has made an impact, especially when combined with earlier and more thoughtful engagement with the CMA,” he said.
A City banker who advises on M&A transactions said a deal between Asda and a non-food retailer would be looked at “more kindly” by the CMA than a merger between two grocers. But they added: “I’m not sure sticking two challenged retailers together is really a good idea.”
Industry figures suggested that Morrisons and Asda could consider a merger, though this has not been explored by either party. Another M&A banker said the two grocer’s overlapping supply networks and store footprints mean a lot of money could be saved in a merger, though the CMA would make such a deal “difficult”.
Richard Hyman, an independent retail analyst, said this option “should not be discounted. However, putting two relatively weak businesses together simply adds scale – it fails to address the key weakness.”
Asda and TDR Capital, its owner, declined to comment.