
Alan Milburn’s review on youth joblessness has urged John Healey to find billions of pounds more in spending each year on young people in order to deliver projected savings in 10 years’ time.
Milburn’s flagship report on helping Britain’s Neets, who are young people out of employment, education and training, has said that the government must allocate £5.8bn more in public funds each year on employment opportunities by 2036.
The report said delivering new investment “should be a priority” in next year’s Spending Review, adding to a multitude of pressures facing the Chancellor around defence funding and public sector pay increases.
Cuts to benefits of around £3.6bn are only set to come into effect from 2036, with initial savings on welfare largely to begin after the next General Election.
Milburn said on Tuesday morning that the government could secure some savings if legislation is passed quickly through parliament as he said “crude cuts” would lead to “more poverty, more penury” as well as higher costs on crime and housing.
Stay in the know
Three daily briefings with the key market moves and top business and political stories.
SUBSCRIBE HEREIn the short term, the government faces the task of finding about £500m in funding from existing departmental budgets for investment to enable under 25-year-olds to enter the national workforce.
Analysis in the Milburn review suggested that cumulative welfare savings between 2030 and 2036 will add up to £13.7bn. Increased tax receipts from greater employment and a 0.4 percentage point addition to GDP each year could mean the Treasury yields a net saving, under Milburn’s projections.
However, when new spending is accounted for, taxpayers are due to save just £200m a year after a decade of new changes.
New problem for Spending Review
The government is due to respond to recommendations in a parliamentary statement this afternoon.
Proposals in the report could set Healey up for a challenging Spending Review as the Chancellor refused to rule out further tax rises last week to deal with a growing list of demands on public finances.
Government figures are also tasked with winning over Labour backbenchers to push through welfare reforms. Pat McFadden, the work and pensions secretary, told MPs on Monday that the government had to “reset the system” and offer a “new settlement for young people”.
The review also called for funding from the apprenticeship levy to be targeted as opportunities for young people. Mayors would also be accountable for delivering services that help under 25-year-old people into the world of work and also gain some of the benefits of welfare savings.
Milburn puts spotlight on Labour’s taxes
The Blair-era health secretary’s core ambition was to reach ‘Neet zero’ in a decade’s time, bringing the rate down from a 13.4 per cent baseline to about five per cent. This would mean that 600,000 more young people were in work, education or training as currently nearly 1m people are Neets.
An interim report in May found that the cost of the Neets crisis totalled about £125bn a year. For every £1 that was spent on employment or education opportunities, about £25 was spent on benefits.
The report also noted the intergenerational gaps in public spending between children and pensioners, which had grown by about 170 per cent between 2004 and 2025.
Reforms in the report include making mayors more accountable for getting young people into work, replacing the health element of Universal Credit with a new youth allowance scheme, adding mental health support and subsidising employers with a £3,000 payment if they take on Neets for at least 6 months.
Milburn also recommended a “glide path” towards cutting employers’ National Insurance contributions by raising the threshold from £5,000 to £10,000 over several years “when fiscal conditions allow”.
The initial cuts for employers hiring 21 to 24-year-olds should be targeted at the retail and hospitality sectors first, according to the former health secretary.
His calls for a partial reveral of Rachel Reeves’ tax hikes bring the Labour government’s previous decisions under renewed scrutiny.
Helen Whately, the shadow work and pensions secretary, said: “Milburn is right to criticise the tax and regulation burdens Labour have imposed on businesses. But his review is too cautious on reversing that damage and too often his answer is the big and expensive hand of the state.
“Overall, it fails to bring down the welfare bill, proposes billions more in government spending and won’t make the slightest difference for young people stuck on welfare now – because nothing will happen for at least three years.”