
Alan Milburn should be commended for his ambition to get NEETs back to work, but in the face of opposition from Labour backbenchers we could end up with more government intervention and subsidy while failing to address the perverse incentives in the welfare system, says Daniel Herring
Today, around 1m, or 13 per cent, of all 16-24 year olds are NEET (not in education, employment or training). Alan Milburn wants to dramatically reduce this to five per cent over a decade. This is a big task – while in countries like the Netherlands and Norway, it’s closer to five per cent, Britain’s figure has consistently stayed above 10 per cent for at least the last 25 years.
So it is fair to say, as Milburn does, that the UK has a structural NEET problem, not just a cyclical one. Milburn’s report is detailed and comprehensive, but the report is an interesting mix of getting government out of the way, some tough love for young people, and then putting government back in the way again.
On getting government out of the way, Milburn takes the government to task on employment costs. Milburn is right to point out that increasing the cost of hiring young people has harmed their employment prospects. Clearly, sharp rises in the minimum wage and employer national insurance are unhelpful for businesses. As the Centre for Policy Studies has shown recently, the rise in employment costs since Labour came to office is double that of inflation.
Milburn rightly suggests reducing employer National Insurance, lightening the burden of regulation and slowing the rise of the minimum wage. These are welcome as a starting point.
Stay in the know
Three daily briefings with the key market moves and top business and political stories.
SUBSCRIBE HERESecondly, tough love in the welfare system. The report notes that the massive rise in health and disability benefits among young people “far outweighs the actual change in ill-health and disability”. Many people are acting rationally: they get more money from the welfare system than through employment. Clearly something is broken, with both the impact on young people’s lives and the fiscal cost becoming a millstone around the country’s neck.
Most people would agree that “work beats welfare” for almost everyone. Milburn’s solution, to create a new youth allowance for anyone under 25 claiming either PIP or the health element of UC, is radical and welcome. Young people will also have a duty to engage or face losing the rest of their benefits. This reform is necessary, and again similar to that previously recommended by the CPS, but it is far from clear that these dramatic changes will get past the parliamentary Labour Party or their activists.
Thirdly, the idea that government needs to get in the way again. I say this partly tongue-in-cheek; there are lots of areas where government can better help young people, and his proposals around apprenticeships and mental health provision are sensible.
Unintended consequences
There are also some areas where I am genuinely conflicted, especially over an increased employment support programme. Currently, only £1 is spent on employment support for every £25 spent on benefits. Milburn wants to get that ratio to £1 of support for every £2 of benefits – hopefully by reducing the bill as well as increasing support. The review proposes that young people should be given guarantees of employment. Much of the work would be assigned to Mayors who will be responsible for ensuring opportunities are available in their local areas.
On the one hand, countries like the Netherlands with low NEET rates do have intensive and localised employment support – people literally knock on doors and get young people into work or training. It makes sense to learn from that. On the other hand, previous British attempts at employment programmes haven’t been especially successful in moving large numbers of people into work. I just don’t trust the British state’s ability to design and run programmes that will actually be cost-effective.
But there are some areas where his proposals will cost money, introduce complexity and have unintended consequences. For example, his proposals to pay employers £3000 to take on young people who are NEET will increase complexity and bureaucracy. It means employers may not take on the best person for the job. Likewise, asking the government to hire more young people or include youth employment in procurement contracts also introduces more bureaucracy. We also need much more accountability from Mayors who are going to be responsible for improving employment outcomes.
Overall, I want to applaud Milburn’s ambition. He is trying to solve a big problem that has an enormous fiscal, economic and moral cost. However, I am concerned about the politics. We know that this Labour Party is highly averse to welfare cuts and loves government intervention. There is a risk that patchy implementation of this review will leave us with the worst of all worlds – pushing ahead with the increased government intervention and subsidy, without addressing the core incentives in the welfare system and reducing regulatory costs and taxes for business.
Daniel Herring is head of economic & fiscal policy at the Centre for Policy Studies