Milburn report is just another licence to bill

Andy Burnham, Mayor of Greater Manchester, in a tuxedo and glasses at a formal event.

There is somewhat of an irony that, on the day that one new Bond was met with unanimous approval, a former Tony Blair disciple has effectively presented the Chancellor with a licence to bill the tax paper even more, says Tim Focas

In a week that has seen Britain finally land a new James Bond, a former Blairite more befitting of the Pierce Brosnan mid-2000s era has dropped the long-awaited review of how to get the young off welfare and into work. It is, therefore, fitting that with the ink barely dry on Alan Milburn’s toe curling ‘Welfare State to a Working State’ report, two-year gilt yields have smashed through the five per cent barrier for the first time in more than three years.

Milburn’s promise to tackle one of Britain’s most expensive economic problems could not come at a more unfortunate time for the treasury, with investors demanding increasingly bigger returns for lending to Britain.

Among many of Milburn’s proposed solutions to the fact that for every £25 spent on benefits for young people just £1 goes towards employment support, is to provide financial incentives for businesses to take on younger people. All with the aim of helping just under 500,000 young people into “sustained employment” over the next decade. While it is hard to argue against the economic rationale of getting young people into meaningful employment, Milburn’s recommendations are not going to come cheap.

His suggestions would trigger annual expenditure to hit £5.8bn by the late 2030s, offset by projected welfare savings of £3.6bn and further tax revenues of £2.4bn. While in theory the maths just about checks out, achieving these numbers depends on the government actually delivering reforms which may take an age to come to fruition in practice.

Stay in the know

Three daily briefings with the key market moves and top business and political stories.

SUBSCRIBE HERE

The problem is that trying to get more youngers into work puts the pressure on the Treasury to subsidise an employment push that its very own tax policies have already made more costly. History tells us that there is no sure fire guarantee that higher taxes on employers generate the expected revenues. However, let’s assume for one second it does, simultaneously it also disincentivises employers from employing younger people and instead replacing them with AI. It is these inexperienced people that Milburn is trying to find work for that will be under an employer’s microscope when it comes to reviewing annual recruitment budgets.

Spend today to save tomorrow?

So the irony of the Milburn review is that Britain will need to spend money today to reduce the burden on taxpayers tomorrow. Consistent rising employment figures, increased GDP and lower risk premiums being demanded by investors on bonds are really the only ways to measure the success of the recommendations if taken on board. But if employers, because of existing policies, come to the view that it is still not worth taking on younger staff despite the incentives and instead employ Claude, the treasury could find itself with higher spending commitments and little revenue coming into the coffers. By the government continuing to increase the cost of employment while simultaneously paying businesses to recruit, it risks undermining the very outcomes Milburn is trying to achieve.

And Britain is in no fit fiscal state to indefinitely rely on a shrinking proportion of its population in productive employment to finance an expanding set of public commitments, and nor can it expect bond investors to overlook the consequences.

There is somewhat of an irony that, on the day that one new Bond was met with unanimous approval, a former Tony Blair disciple has effectively presented the Chancellor with a licence to bill the tax paper even more. With two year gilt yields above five per cent, coupled with the fact that 10 and 20 year yields are still above five per cent, unless John Healey shows that this hefty bill to achieve true welfare reform eventually pays for itself, then Britain’s next mission will make Pattinson’s reported fee per film seem like chicken feed.

Tim Focas is head of Capital Markets at Aspectus Group

Original source Milburn report is just another licence to bill

Back to home