‘Massive expansion of the state’: Milburn report sows Tory and Labour division on welfare

Pat McFadden speaking at a podium during a press conference, addressing current general news topics.

Tory frontbenchers and the government’s youth unemployment tsar Alan Milburn have sparred over approaches to welfare reform, which are set to underpin major policy proposals at the next election. 

On Tuesday, Milburn called for a complete redesign of the welfare and employment system for under 25-year-olds in a bid to reduce the rate of young people not in employment, education or training (Neets) from about 13 per cent to five per cent by 2036. 

Proposals in his review are set to bring different parties’ welfare and wider economic plans under the microscope after the former Tony Blair-era health secretary insisted that his recommendations “fit together as one package”. 

The Tories offered a mixed response to the review, having already pledged to cut the overall welfare bill by up to £36bn.

While Milburn insisted he did not want his report to be partisan after discussing policies with opposition parties, the former Labour minister said “crude cuts” to benefits without accompanying employment support was not “defensible morally, anymore than I believe it will work fiscally”. 

Stay in the know

Three daily briefings with the key market moves and top business and political stories.

SUBSCRIBE HERE

At a press conference held in Google’s offices in central London, Milburn noted that there were still political figures proposing “crude cuts” without explicitly naming the Conservatives or Reform UK, which are pledging billions of pounds in welfare savings to fund multi-billion pound tax cuts. 

However, the former Tony Blair-era health secretary did condemn former Chancellor Rachel Reeves’ plans to cut welfare spending by £5bn as a “fiscal grab”, warning “that is not the way of doing it”. 

‘We need a change in incentives’

Speaking about his proposals to increase investment on employment support up front, he also said: “There is plenty of scope for changing how we spend money.”

Ryan Shorthouse, the Executive Chair of centre-right think tank Bright Blue, said the proposals do not address the underlying issue of misaligned incentives.

“To reduce the NEET rate, we need a significant change in incentives, not a significant increase in public investment. Bluntly, we need to make it cheaper for employers to hire young adults and harder for young adults to claim health-related benefits.”

Shorthouse added that “the Milburn Review is a very Blairite plan: new statutory tests, targets and guarantees” amounting to “bigger and bossier government.”

‘Expansion in size of the state’

In the House of Commons, work and pensions secretary Pat McFadden said a new unit would be created in government to respond directly to Milburn’s series of recommendations while a white paper on proposed welfare would be introduced in the new year.  

But Helen Whately, the shadow work and pensions secretary, suggested the Tories did not wholly agree with the list of plans set out by Milburn. 

Whately said the report “trashed” the government’s economic decisions after new employment rights and tax rises introduced by Labour were criticised in the near-200-page document. 

While the Tory frontbencher backed Milburn’s move to change the welfare system to stop people with anxiety, ADHD, autism or depression from becoming “trapped in economic activity”, she criticised calls for “a massive expansion in the size and responsibilities of the state”. 

Benefits dilemma in Milburn report

She also argued that, under Milburn’s proposals, spending would increase as just £3.6bn of cuts to benefits were laid out.  

She told MPs: “Milburn is a savvy politician. He knows his most important audience is the Labour backbenchers before me, who want to raise taxes to pay more in benefits. 

“So it is no wonder that the lion’s share of what this review recommends is a massive spending plan and a massive expansion of the role of government. 

“Almost £6bn more of taxpayers’ money on thousands of government-subsidised work placements to compensate for the real jobs Labour policies have destroyed.”

McFadden took a dig at Whately, replying: “In the space of a few minutes, she told the House that Alan Milburn has copied the Conservative plan, and also that the plan is reckless Labour spending money.”

Mandelson files released earlier this year revealed McFadden‘s frustration with getting welfare reforms past backbenchers. He told the former US ambassador in a message: “Every meeting I have is: ‘Who can we tax in order to pay benefits to others?’ They’re asking the wrong questions.”

Original source ‘Massive expansion of the state’: Milburn report sows Tory and Labour division on welfare

Back to home