Mansion tax inspectors snooping on your home is a gross violation of privacy

HMRC officer photographing a London terrace house, conducting an inspection of the property

The ‘mansion tax’ is pure extortion and inspectors should not be able to take photographs of your home to abet what amounts to theft, says Charles Amos

Whitehall instructions for mansion tax inspectors to photograph homes without owners’ consent are a gross invasion of privacy. No tax inspector has a right to take photos for the purposes of enforcing the mansion tax because the mansion tax itself is pure extortion: It is nothing but a revenue raising exercise to further soak the productive parts of the country, i.e. London and the south east. Yet again Labour are demonstrating they have no regard for private property; not even in that most tender area of our lives – our own homes.

Taxation only has two good justifications: helping the truly destitute and protecting people against foreign invaders and domestic criminals. The state’s budget is already £1.4 trillion, more than enough to finance the two purposes mentioned, meaning, the £430m to be raised from the mansion tax amounts to pure extortion of the rich. Taking £2,500 from a £2m homeowner in Chelsea via the mansion tax to fund leisure centres, bus shelters and libraries in Hartlepool is theft: We’d never accept a private person taking that money for such purposes because the need is not serious enough in any of the three cases, nor should the state. Certainly, when the state is funding £145bn of working age and child welfare this should be redirected to any essential needs local councils might still have first before raising yet more tax. 

Even if you don’t get on board with this libertarian argument though, surely, it must be agreed people should pull their own weight. The local government secretary, Steve Reed, says it’s unjust that a £10m Band H house in Mayfair pays £2,100 in council tax currently while a £400,000 Band D house in Blackpool pays £2,500. Yet the rich householder in Mayfair justly pays less than the poorer householder of Blackpool because the Londoner uses fewer services and the Blackpooler far more. Plus: Some council tax is much lower because the councils are run a lot better, such as Wandsworth. Reed should not simply look at lower figures and punish residents with higher taxes which might well just amount to a surcharge for efficiency! 

Now we have established the mansion tax is pure extortion we can see why taking photos of people’s homes is wrong. An analogy helps. If burglars were taking photos of homes deliberately so they could size them up to only break into the most plentifully stocked, then we’d be quite right in taking their cameras and smashing them to pieces. Although taking pictures of people’s homes is not per se wrong, where doing so is part of an unjust scheme it becomes wrong too. Tax inspectors taking pictures of people’s homes to present them with a massive bill and then threaten them with jail for nonpayment are taking part in an unjust scheme, so, their photography becomes wrongful. If an invasion of privacy is taken to include taking photos you’ve no right to take, then tax inspectors invade privacy. 

Stay in the know

Three daily briefings with the key market moves and top business and political stories.

SUBSCRIBE HERE

Steve Reed will, of course, dispute the very foundation of my argument. As a Labour politician who believes in some form of egalitarianism, he has no ultimate concern for private property, or, indeed, home ownership, because both stand in the way of equality. Along with Sir Edward Coke, I say: “An Englishman’s home is his castle’. It doesn’t matter how you’ve justly acquired it, via luck or hard work, it should be a sacred place which goes entirely undisturbed. Your home is your own and Labour ought to stay out of it. And not photograph it either.

Charles Amos writes The Musing Individualist Substack

Original source Mansion tax inspectors snooping on your home is a gross violation of privacy

Back to home