
An NHS-style legal service could be funded by siphoning off interest on lawyers’ client accounts, which the City’s law bodies have warned would be a fresh tax blow to firms.
The Justice Committee called on the Ministry of Justice (MoJ) on 19 November to create a national legal service “to improve people’s access to justice and address unmet legal need”.
The national legal service would provide people with legitimate legal information and options for getting appropriate support in the same way the NHS 111 helpline does.
The Committee recommended the government should raise additional revenue to fund the service through a “portfolio” of funding mechanisms, including through an Interest on Lawyers’ Client Accounts (ICLA) scheme.
It said this “could provide substantial amounts of funding, as comparable schemes do in other jurisdictions.”
Stay in the know
Three daily briefings with the key market moves and top business and political stories.
SUBSCRIBE HEREThe government’s plans to cut interest on law firms’ client accounts to fund the justice department was introduced by the Ministry of Justice’s previous secretary of state for justice, David Lammy, in January.
Colin Passmore, chair of the Square Mile’s law body, the City of London Law Society (CLLS), told that funding the service through interest in lawyers’ client accounts “would amount to another form of taxation on the solicitors’ profession, following the abandoned City levy and last year’s NIC proposals.”
“The CLLS supports the ambition behind a National Legal Service. Improving access to justice is a goal the whole profession shares, and a properly resourced system is long overdue,” Passmore said.
“However, we do not believe that diverting interest on lawyers’ client accounts is an appropriate means of funding it,” he said, adding, “a service of this importance requires sustainable and transparent public funding, rather than a hidden charge on client money.”
He said the proposal would “fall hardest on smaller firms across the country, which provide vital services to their clients. Ultimately, it would increase costs for the very people the scheme is intended to help.”
Scheme risks ‘causing an unnecessary new storm of bureaucracy’
In September, the City’s legal sector warned against the introduction of such a scheme ahead of the Autumn Budget, raising concerns it could drive some law firms out of business.
The Law Society of England and Wales reiterated those concerns in regards to the national legal service.
“Any potential use of the ILCA scheme by the MoJ to tax law firm clients puts high street law firms at high risk due to rising fees, as well as causing an unnecessary new storm of bureaucracy,” Brett Dixon, president of the Law Society, said.
Dixon added that “rather than pursuing a flawed proposal that has attracted widespread opposition, the UK government should focus on sustainable, long-term investment in the justice system that does not involve raiding clients’ money.”
A Ministry of Justice spokesperson said in a statement the department is “exploring how to build a more integrated legal support system, including a National Legal Service, to help people get support sooner.”