
As the Immigration and Asylum Bill enters report stage today, the UK government will debate whether to implement a new appeals body. But the proposal to establish that within the Home Office creates a conflict of interest, writes Law Society president Brett Dixon
As the Immigration and Asylum Bill passes through Parliament, the UK government has the opportunity to build a system that delivers fair, accurate and final decisions. In its current form, however, the Bill misses that opportunity.
The government is right to want faster and more reliable immigration decisions. But the proposal to establish a new appeals body within the Home Office creates a conflict of interest, as the government department whose decisions are challenged would also house the body reviewing the decisions. This arrangement raises questions about the body’s independence.
No government should be able to influence immigration appeals
We must be able to trust that when a government decision is challenged, it will be reviewed fairly and independently. Clear safeguards are essential to maintain public confidence in decisions.
The solution to reducing pressure in the appeal system is to get decisions right the first time. This means investing in good quality decision making and increasing the availability of legal aid to support this.
Stay in the know
Three daily briefings with the key market moves and top business and political stories.
SUBSCRIBE HEREIf the government proceeds with the new appeals body, it needs to demonstrate how its independence will be protected in practice. This includes independence in how senior staff are appointed, how decisions are made about whether particular cases should be accelerated and how the body’s decisions are reviewed.
Under the Bill, senior appointments would be made by the secretary of state, compromising the body’s independence. No government, present or future, should be able to exercise inappropriate influence over the outcome of an immigration or asylum appeal.
New rules will move the goal posts
Ensuring all decision makers have legal qualifications and expertise is equally as important. This will help reduce errors and delays in complex immigration and asylum cases that have huge implications on people’s lives.
The questions of fairness and legal certainty extend beyond the appeals system.
The Bill should also be considered alongside the government’s wider earned settlement reforms. Requiring refugees to remain on temporary paths for substantially longer periods risks prolonging uncertainty for people who need stability and security to rebuild their lives. Taken together, the asylum and settlement reforms make legal certainty, access to legal advice and effective independent scrutiny of Home Office decision-making even more important.
The new rules move the goal posts for those who have already accepted jobs, moved their families, built careers and contributed to the UK based on the system that was in place when they made their plans and arrived.
Employers also need certainty
That uncertainty does not stop with individuals and their families. Employers who benefit from international talent also need to be sure that the rules they recruit under will not unexpectedly change, exposing them to heavy administrative and financial burden.
If workers decide the UK is no longer a predictable and stable place to build their future, businesses and the wider economy will feel the consequences. Applying significant changes to settlement retrospectively further undermines that certainty and risks eroding confidence in the fairness and predictability of the immigration system.
English and Welsh law is respected around the world because it embodies the rule of law and access to justice. Immigration and asylum cannot be treated as somehow separate from those fundamental principles.
The proposed reforms will command confidence only if its decisions are accurate, appeals are genuinely independent and its rules can be relied upon.