
The shipping industry has a reputation for being boom and bust.
There might be some justification for this, but the perception is more extreme than reality, says Nikos Petrakakos, portfolio manager of Tufton Assets – an investment trust that, instead of holding stocks and shares, holds a portfolio of commercial ships that it leases.
That provides an accessible way for private investors to gain exposure to the otherwise esoteric shipping industry. Tufton Assets trades on the specialist funds segment of the London Stock Exchange with the fitting ticker of (LON: SHIP).
Start your trial of MoneyWeek today
Get unparalleled financial insight, analysis and expert opinion you can profit from.
Start your trial
Sign up for MoneyWeek’s free twice-daily newsletter.
Join more than 165,000 subscribers and keep yourself informed with latest financial news, insights and expert analysis to help you understand what really matters when it comes to your finances.
Join more than 165,000 subscribers and keep yourself informed with latest financial news, insights and expert analysis to help you understand what really matters when it comes to your finances.
Its portfolio is a fleet of 21 commercial shipping vessels that it charters to generate income. The fleet is made up of roughly half bulkers and half product tankers, with a small number of chemical tankers.
Tufton says the fleet is diversified by vessel type, age, charterer and charter length, to reduce reliance on any single market, customer or vessel.
Speaking to Cris Sholto Heaton on the podcast, also available to watch on YouTube, Petrakakos said: “There’s indeed a lot of fortunes made and lost. The volatility of it comes from how the construction cycle works for new ships – typically two years in an average market and, when you have a big backlog like now, it could be upwards of four years.
“You’re ordering based on a market today,” he continued. “So sometimes when you have extreme euphoria in a market [there is] an undersupply of ships and then suddenly people are ordering based on the current market and by the time these ships get delivered, whatever was creating that uplift is potentially gone and suddenly you have an oversupply.”
This being said, Petrakakos says volatility can be very different between sectors and even within each sub-sector.
Returns on larger container ships that carry only one type of commodity, like crude oil, tend to be more volatile than those on smaller ships that carry a more diverse range of goods to a larger number of ports.
Petrakakos said that what creates the boom-bust reputation of the industry is people intentionally playing the market with a very defined timeline and overlevering.
“That’s what’s created the bust for people,” he said. “That’s the recipe for disaster.”
How the closure of the Strait of Hormuz has impacted the shipping industry
Since 28 February, the conflict between Iran and the United States has led to increased volatility in the Middle East.
One particularly economically damaging aspect is the closure of the Strait of Hormuz, a narrow waterway between Iran and Oman through which around 20% of the world’s oil and gas supply travels.
The consequences of this have rippled far beyond the immediate area.
For example, many large ships carrying crude oil and liquified natural gas that would previously have been carrying cargos from the Middle East have been plying other routes instead.
“What’s changed is the longer distances,” said Petrakakos. “Instead of going from the Persian Gulf or Arabian Gulf to Asia, now those have to come through the Americas primarily or West Coast Africa.
“On top of that the Suez canal is shut as well because of Houthi attacks so you end up having something that would normally take 25 to 30 days taking 45 or more days.”
More of these ships tied up on longer routes means fewer available to charter at any given point, pushing up rates for them, but also for other classes of ships as well.
For example, with the supply of oil and gas constrained, the demand for coal has increased. Coal is carried in a class of ships called dry bulk carriers, which are also used to transport other bulky commodities. This has benefitted Tufton, even though its own bulkers are not chartered out to carry coal.
“There’s more ships carrying coal, which means there’s fewer ships there to carry the other commodities that we [Tufton] tend to carry. So it ends up lifting the entire market.”
Why shipping is like booking an Uber
While Tufton Assets doesn’t own any very large crude carriers (VLCCs), as the giant oil tankers are called, demand for the types of product and chemical tankers that it operates has also been strong.
That’s partly because a loss of refinery capacity in some regions is also forcing these vessels to make longer runs, and partly because in such a tight market, smaller vessels may be substituted for larger ones in certain roles.
“So the entire market has been lifted because of a lack of supply,” said Petrakakos. “A similar example would be Uber’s [surge pricing].
“You might have more drivers than passengers, but if all the passengers are in one area and there is disruption – traffic or an accident – you’ll still have the surge pricing even though you have enough cars to carry them.
“They’re just in the wrong place at the wrong time or there’s something blocking them, and that’s pretty much what’s happening in shipping.”
For more on the outlook for the shipping industry, Tufton’s investment strategy, and the pitfalls investors in the sector should avoid, listen to the full podcast episode with Nikos Petrakakos, available wherever you get your podcasts.
About the podcast
is a podcast that helps you unlock the secrets to financial success. Editors Kalpana Fitzpatrick, Andrew Van Sickle and Cris Sholto Heaton are joined by influential guests – from CEOs and entrepreneurs to economists and fund managers – to share their top tips on managing money, investing wisely and building wealth.