
Only around one in seven high earners caught in the £100,000 income tax trap used personal pension contributions to drag themselves back under the threshold, data obtained by shows.
Roughly 192,000 self-assessment taxpayers had taxable income between £100,000 and £125,140 during the 2024/25 tax year before relief at source pension contributions were deducted, according to figures obtained from HMRC via a Freedom of Information request.
But of this cohort just 27,000, representing around 14 per cent, paid enough into relief at source schemes to bring themselves back under the threshold.
Relief at source schemes are methods of securing tax relief on personal or workplace pension contributions, where you pay into your pension using money that has already been taxed, better known as take-home pay.
Tangled up
The freezing of tax thresholds, combined with rising wages, has dragged more Brits into a tax trap in which they pay a 60 per cent marginal rate if they earn between £100,000 to £125,140.
Stay in the know
Three daily briefings with the key market moves and top business and political stories.
SUBSCRIBE HEREThose within this earning bracket face an effective marginal income tax rate of 60 per cent, because the £12,570 personal allowance is tapered away by £1 for every £2 earned over the threshold.
Personal allowance has been fixed at £12,570 since April 2021 and is currently not due to rise until the 2031/32 tax year.
But making pension contributions can reduce an individual’s net income, allowing those above the threshold to restore their personal allowance and claim higher-rate tax relief.
Failing to take advantage of reduction schemes can deal a particular blow to workers with young children, as it turns a pay rise into a loss. Once the £100,000 earnings threshold is surpassed, free childcare hours are lost.
In dual households, individual salaries are taken into account meaning childcare hours are taken the moment one parent crosses the £100,000 line regardless of what the other earns.
Raising awareness
Philly Ponniah, a financial coach for high earners, noted that “14 per cent is only part of the story” as many high earners will use salary sacrifice schemes to reduce their gross pay.
Employees effectively take a pay cut in exchange for higher pension contributions, dragging them back down under the threshold. It differs from relief at source, as it reduces gross pay before tax and national insurance is calculated.
But salary sacrifice is set to be pared back in April 2029, with the tax free exemption to be capped at £2,000, which could make relief at source a more lucrative choice.
Ponniah noted that some Brits choose not to use relief at source due to tax year timings, while others are unaware of the trap and how to avoid it.
“Relief at source contributions have to be made within the tax year, and if you’re self-employed or a landlord you often don’t know your final income until after 5 April, by which point it’s too late,” she said.
“There’s awareness…the trap has been around since 2010, but many people still don’t know about it, or don’t realise they have to claim the higher-rate relief through their tax return. I have encountered quite a few people who did not realise they had to claim the tax relief back.”