
A new wave of restaurants and pubs are descending on Smithfield Market, writes Carys Sharkey
There’s something wonderfully anachronistic about Smithfield’s place in the City. A meat market inside meat market. On a Thursday afternoon come July or December, lawyers and consultants white-knuckling lagers spill onto the roads that coil around the squat Victorian building. All the while, broad-set men, white overalls turned pink from assorted viscera, shunt carcasses from lorries. It’s possibly my favourite area of London. Where else can you get Chinese-style three roast meats and a full English at midnight courtesy of Farriers Cafe before buying half a pig, while chapped-handed butchers start their day as the last-trainers to Kent slope off sideways?
But Smithfield is facing a period of enormous change. The City of London wants to move the Market to Albert Island in the Docklands (a real loss for the area), while later this month, the London Museum will reopen in its new Smithfield home after 10 years of renovations and £437m spent (a real gain for the area). But one constant for Smithfield is the quality of its restaurant scene, which is only set to get better and better.
You can’t talk about food in this part of the city without talking about St John. Opened in Smithfield in 1994, Fergus Henderson’s truly trailblazing restaurant has cast its marrowbone shadow over London, and will continue to do so, for a very long time. More recently, Bouchon Racine – the UK’s best restaurant – has been delighting Londoners with Lyonnaise heft. Luca has become one of the city’s best Italian restaurants. St Barts has quietly been serving an electric take on British fine dining, while Cloth is a picture-perfect still life of a restaurant. And still there’s Farriers Cafe with its chips and fried rice.
This year has already seen a smattering of new, highly hyped openings in and around the area. Public House Group – the West London-cum-Cotswolds team behind the likes of The Pelican and The Fat Badger – opened The Horses in September. A fish-focused pub with their trademark Flemish chic aesthetic. In the same month, The George and Dragon, a beautiful pub on St John Street, opened. Downstairs is a boozer with mosaics and walls pock-marked by Blitz bombing, and upstairs is Island, a surf and turf restaurant by Tom Brown and Brad Carter.
Stay in the know
Three daily briefings with the key market moves and top business and political stories.
SUBSCRIBE HEREMock turtle soup at B. Penhale
But some of the most exciting openings are still to come. Together with restaurateurs Clare Lattin, Ratnesh Bagdai and Tom Hill, chef Elliot Hashtroudi will follow up his hugely popular, guts-and-all French restaurant Camille, with B. Penhale. The restaurant opened this week in the former home of Club Gascon, within spitting distance of the Market. For Hashtroudi, whose great-grandmother’s butchers had ties with Smithfield and who himself trained at St John, this feels like a bit of a homecoming. The restaurant is named after his grandma and it’s got St John DNA pulsing through it.
“When I first met Fergus Henderson, he told me, ‘change can be a good thing’. It was spoken with omniscience and left an imprint on me,” Hashtroudi tells me when I ask what it means to be part of the Smithfield new wave.

“It’s important to preserve tradition and honour it, but with change, I aim to emphasise these things. The food itself is a bit of a history lesson, and the building oozes nostalgia. I’ve always believed it’s good to give in to nostalgia, not run from it.”
B. Penhale might be a new opening, but at its core, it’s a monument to the past, and a fitting tribute to Hashtroudi’s grandmother, Betty Penhale.
“She’s a devil for a cup of tea; in fact, it’s her only source of hydration. There’s a special tea course in her honour. She makes a great Scouse, which comes out once or twice a year. That’ll find its way onto the menu at some stage,” Hashtroudi says.
B. Penhale’s menu reads like a history book. Described as ‘regional British and Irish’, Hashtroudi says the food is “very region-specific”. It’s an exercise in archaeology: the careful rediscovery and preservation of our food culture. Dishes like Dublin coddle, Scottish Ecclefechan tart, Cornish charter pie and mock turtle soup all appear on the menu. To find out what they are, you’ll just have to go.
The Poet finds its voice
A three-minute walk down West Smithfield lands you at the site of what’s set to be another welcome addition to the area. Opening at the end of the month in one of the six ‘Houses’ surrounding the London Museum development, The Poet is a new pub and restaurant from Spencer Large, Honey Spencer and Charlie Sims, the team behind Hackney’s Sune. The Poet takes its name from John Betjeman, who lived round the corner in Cloth Fair and wrote poems extolling how the new Metropolitan Line could whisk you and your lover away from Farringdon to Ruislip. But with The Poet he stays home, and becomes part of London’s next chapter.
“Betjeman was a massive advocate for protecting historic buildings in London. However, he also believed that history is not static and that cities like London are constantly evolving,” co-founder Sims tells me. The building, which the team immediately fell in love with after years of looking, has undergone a huge amount of work in order to open later this month.
“Our site is a beautiful old Victorian building which has been many things over the last century or so, including a dairy, a tailor and a bistro in the nineties called Bubb’s (which featured in The Spice World movie). It is the first time that it will be a pub, which for us, is very exciting. We feel the building is crying out for it.”

The Poet team might be “buzzing to be in a part of London that is undergoing a real evolution”, but it’s not without due reverence for what’s come before. Sims pours praise on Luca and says Bouchon Racine is maybe his favourite restaurant in the city. He says that when he and his wife and co-founder Honey Spencer lived in Copenhagen, their first stop on the way back from the airport would be to St John for kidneys on toast.
So it’s fitting that the menu draws on the pubby-Britishness and nose to tail-ness that goes hand in hand with Smithfield. Under executive chef Charlie Tayler, formerly of Aulis and The Ledbury, the kitchen will put out fun, slightly cheeky-chappy dishes like Scampi Fries Scotch egg and black pudding sausage roll, while upstairs in the dining room it’s elevated-pub grub à la lamb shanks and suet puddings. If the success of new City spot Cloth Cornhill is anything to go by, this menu is going to be a hit. The Poet will also serve a set menu celebrating all parts of the chicken over four to five courses – including in the pudding – as an homage to the meat market. It’s a sign, perhaps, of serious ambition masquerading as a very good pub. Next year the team plans to open Envoi, a 10-seat chef’s table, in the building. And considering Tayler’s Michelin background, you can see why.
Smithfield will always have one foot in the past even as it is bundled into the future. It’s apt that our ties to the Market’s history, one of food, hard graft and conviviality, will live on in this wave of new restaurants and pubs. As a wise man once said, “change can be a good thing”.