
The consultation on Founders’ Relief consultation is open until the end of the month, so entrepreneurs unhappy with the rules should make their case, says Tim Sarson
I was up early the morning after the Budget for a Westminster breakfast event with a few dozen entrepreneurs. As you’d expect, everyone’s favourite talking point was Chancellor John Healey’s surprise announcement of a new capital gains tax relief for founders.
Were they thrilled to be prioritised? Based on this sample, the jury is out. They told me they’d read the small print of the initial plan and didn’t love how narrowly the qualification conditions had been framed.
I came away reminded that details matter however noble any government’s intention. For this group of business owners, the reality doesn’t yet match the rhetoric, but they stand ready to discuss the detail with government.
Meanwhile, across London in the City and Canary Wharf, the large banks’ share prices were moderately chipper despite them having been hit by a temporary hike in the banking surcharge. It wasn’t as bad as some had feared.
Stay in the know
Three daily briefings with the key market moves and top business and political stories.
SUBSCRIBE HEREA nice case study in taxpayer psychology and expectation management.
But, the thing is, that Founders’ Relief small print that got everyone hot under the collar is actually still up for discussion. On Budget day, HMRC launched new formal consultations covering this and a range of other topics. So, if entrepreneurs are unhappy with the way the new rules have been drawn up, they have until the end of this month to make their points known.
And they should. Contrary to popular belief, the Treasury and HMRC do listen and act on feedback. Not always, of course, but at least 15 measures in this year’s Budget showed the marks of both formal consultation and informal industry discussions. Among other things these included admin simplifications for research and development claims, new guidance on pre-development costs, a reduced threshold for the Advance Tax clearance Service, Founders’ Relief itself and the U-turn on dropping the Cash ISA threshold.
Make your views known
Businesses can make their views known in several ways. Early on in policy formation, the Treasury or HMRC sometimes issue open-ended calls for evidence. These allow affected taxpayers as well as those representing them, like my own firm and organisations such as the CBI or 100 Group, to comment on the principles and practicalities of different options for dealing with a particular challenge. The call for evidence on business rates and investment was one recent example.
Further on in the process, they put firm policies and draft legislation out for consultation. This is the time for scrutiny on how legislation will actually work, whether it will achieve what it sets out to do and whether the administrative burden involved is reasonable or excessive. That’s the stage we’re now at with Founders’ Relief.
Outside these formal processes both officials and ministers regularly meet with businesses to get a feel for things like take-up of a new incentive or the potential admin burden from a new reporting requirement.
It’s easy to be cynical about this. Taxpayer groups get frustrated if their concerns don’t seem to be taken on board. It’s true they won’t always get what they want, but the government can and does change its mind when faced with difficult facts. Notably, if it becomes clear industry is not going to be ready for a major change in time, HMRC have often acted to delay or modify the implementation timetable.
On the other side, it’s also easy to be suspicious of a too cozy relationship between “big business and the taxman”. But the fact is dialogue between our fiscal authorities and those affected by their measures is essential if we’re not to have rules that are impossible to administer or behavioural responses that undermine the point of legislation.
Our approach to consultation certainly isn’t perfect, but I think it treads the line between coziness and the unheeding state reasonably well. In some countries there are more obvious links between industry interests and national or regional policy, and that’s great for the corporates with access but can it lend itself to anticompetitive policy, trade protectionism and conflicts of interest. In some others, the relationship is so distant or toxic that there can be no meeting of minds.
The mechanisms are in place here in the UK. But consultation can only work if we have willing participants. My message to those founders at the post-Budget breakfast was the same as my message to readers today: “Don’t ask, don’t get”.
Tim Sarson is head of tax policy at KPMG