Exclusive: Timms welfare review to dismiss change to Pip eligibility

Burnham cityscape showcasing modern architecture, bustling streets, and vibrant community life in a thriving urban setting

A government-led review into disability payments will not demand a tightening on eligibility to claims, according to people briefed on the matter, setting Andy Burnham up for a clash between welfare reform for under 25-year-olds and other adults. 

Sir Stephen Timms’ welfare review, which is set to be published on Tuesday, will suggest that claimants of  disability benefits should not be compelled to take up support offered to help people into work, volunteering or other activities, understands.

People claiming personal independence payments (Pips) should also retain access to cash support, the report is expected to conclude. Timms, who is the disability minister, was not mandated to deliver savings ahead of writing the report as he was told to publish findings according to existing projected spending levels. 

The total welfare bill excluding pensioner spending is set to total about £183bn this year, with the Office for Budget Responsibility showing that Pips contribute to about £50bn of the spending figure. Disability benefits are also set to grow as a share of GDP between the years 2026 and 2032. 

Both the Milburn and Timms reviews’ reflections on spending figures have come into focus due to the rise in borrowing costs, a near-record high tax burden and pressures for the Chancellor to fund defence and public infrastructure around the country.

Stay in the know

Three daily briefings with the key market moves and top business and political stories.

SUBSCRIBE HERE

Ahead of the report’s publication, the Institute for Fiscal Studies’ senior research economist Eduin Latimer said that report “should expect claimant numbers to rise and therefore be clear about how eligibility or generosity would be reduced in order to control the costs of the system”.

Burnham’s welfare ‘philosophy’

Timms’ recommendations could put Burnham in a difficult position after the Prime Minister suggested he wanted to apply the “philosophy” behind Alan Milburn’s report on youth unemployment to the wider welfare system. 

Earlier this week, Milburn recommended that benefits for young people should be cut by about £3.6bn a year by tightening eligibility criteria, which could involve some people with anxiety, depression or ADHD to “get less financial support at the beginning of their benefit claim than under the current system”. 

Cuts to benefits on the health element of Universal Credit will be superseded by a near-£6bn injection of investment in employment support under Milburn’s plans. 

The Tony Blair-era health secretary has now been appointed to a government role to lead reforms of the welfare and employment system for those aged between 16 and 24. 

On Friday morning, it was reported in the Financial Times that there could be reforms introduced to distinguish different health conditions. 

The Timms review has focused on increasing capacity for face-to-face assessments, ensuring that people can access the welfare system by easier means, and curb the number of reviews for people with lifelong or degenerative conditions. 

Tricky territory for Labour

The disability minister was commissioned to write the year-long review after Labour backbenchers rebelled against Sir Keir Starmer and Rachel Reeves’ plans to slash the benefits bill by about £5bn in mid-2025. 

The cuts divided the party and severely weakened support for the former Prime Minister. 

Cabinet ministers Louise Haigh and Anneliese Midgley were in the 127-strong rebel group that  signed an amendment opposing the cuts. 

Burnham has insisted he wanted to “get the welfare bill down” but would not impose “crude cuts”. 

Opposition figures have meanwhile pledged drastic welfare reforms in order to fund proposed tax cuts. 

Shadow work and pensions secretary Helen Whateley has pledged to cut the bill by £36bn if the Tories are elected, mainly by tightening eligibility for claimants, slashing access to some foreign nationals and re-introducing a two-child benefit cap. 

Reform UK has meanwhile promised to cut the bill by £50bn through more radical reforms. 

A DWP spokesperson said: “Supporting disabled people to participate fully in life will always be our top priority.

“The Timms Review interim report made clear, PIP is no longer fit for purpose.

“When the final report is published, we will consider the recommendations alongside the Milburn review.”

Original source Exclusive: Timms welfare review to dismiss change to Pip eligibility

Back to home