Court bans China’s BYD from selling ‘Defender clone’ SUV in EU

Chinese carmaker BYD has been banned from selling its "Defender clone" vehicle in the EU by a court in the Netherlands, after Jaguar Land Rover (JLR) brought a case saying it infringed intellectual property rights.

JLR launched legal action over the seven-seater Ti7 SUV earlier this year after BYD announced on its website that it was taking orders from UK customers for the vehicle. Earlier this month, bailiffs acting for JLR were reported to have seized digital records from BYD's offices.

"In these summary proceedings, the preliminary relief judge rules that ​the Ti7 infringes the EU design of Jaguar Land Rover," said the ruling from the district court in The Hague. "The characteristic ⁠and distinctive elements of the design are reflected in the BYD Ti7."

Close up photo of the front of the SUV

The ban will take effect one week after Friday's ruling, which noted that BYD "currently has no concrete plans to place the Ti7 on the market in the EU". The judge ruled, however, that the court had no jurisdiction over BYD's activities in the UK.

BYD's plug-in hybrid SUV, which has been on sale in China since last September, has been likened by motoring experts to the Land Rover Defender, with the BBC's Top Gear magazine calling it the "Chinese Defender clone".

According to BYD's website: "An unapologetically boxy profile delivers the imposing, chunky design that finds favour among SUV buyers, yet delivers a contemporary look."

The Ti7 has gone on sale in the UK for £47,995, more than £20,000 cheaper than the Defender, with deliveries to customers due from January 2027.

JLR's seven-seat Defender is one of the UK's bestselling cars and is the company's most popular model. The UK-based carmaker, which is owned by India's Tata Motors, sold 29,500 Defenders to retail customers between July and September this year, an increase of more than 4,000 on the same period a year earlier.

JLR said in a statement: "We protect our intellectual property and take legal action when necessary. Legal proceedings are ongoing and we won't be commenting ​further at this time."

In ​a statement, BYD ⁠said it "strongly disagrees" with the ruling and will appeal. "The BYD Ti7 is the result of BYD's own independent design work and infringes none of JLR's rights," BYD said. "We will pursue every legal avenue to demonstrate that this decision ⁠is incorrect."

The court also banned BYD from producing the vehicle at its new factory at Szeged in Hungary, which is expected to start producing cars at the end of 2026, until the intellectual property case is resolved.

While many traditional carmakers have complained for some time that Chinese competitors have copied their designs, until now little has been tested in court. It is it relatively rare for European automakers to go to court over infringement of design rights.

However, JLR previously won a legal case to stop Jiangling Motors Corporation selling a copycat vehicle in 2019, after a three-year court battle.

Original source Court bans China’s BYD from selling ‘Defender clone’ SUV in EU

Back to home