
There’s been much speculation about AI’s impact on the employment market. Predictions vary across a wide spectrum, from the anti-luddite “AI will displace jobs, not replace them” approach all the way to the Elon Musk-style “work will soon be optional” thesis.
So far, there is very little hard data available to furnish the more alarmist views. According to the latest data, while at 4.7 per cent the current level of UK unemployment is well above the sub-four per cent post-pandemic lows, the rate remains below the 21st century average of 5.4 per cent.
Last month, analysed news reports of mass UK layoffs over the past two years, spanning more than 130,000 roles. The companies behind the cuts were much more likely to attribute the layoffs to higher costs, including rising taxes, than they were to automation.
Ben Caswell, senior economist at the National Institute of Economic and Social Research, says there is no “smoking gun evidence” that AI had been a major cause of the steady rise in unemployment and decline in vacancies in the UK, which were “quite broad-based.”
That being said, in some parts of the economy the effect of AI on the labour market is becoming more pronounced.
Stay in the know
Three daily briefings with the key market moves and top business and political stories.
SUBSCRIBE HEREAmong the first victims to the technology has been call centre jobs, which are rapidly on the decline. Sky, for instance, last year said it would cut as many as 2,000 call centre jobs last year as part of a shift to “digital self-service.”
There has also been a sharp drop in hiring at professional services firms like PwC and Deloitte, though arguably some of this can be put down to pandemic-era overhiring.
But there is one part of the economy rapidly where AI’s advance is becoming clear: financial services.
Banks, insurance firms and pension funds are shedding jobs at speed. To name a few: HSBC has cut more than four thousand (the medium-term target could be as high as twenty thousand), Barclays is cutting five thousand, Standard Chartered more than seven thousand.
L&G has cemented its position on the league table today, confirming earlier reports that it has set into motion a plan to axe 1,000 roles.
“We continue to take action to make L&G simpler, more efficient and more competitive, building on the progress we have made since 2024,” the FTSE 100 firm said this morning.
“As part of this programme, we commenced a staff redundancy exercise in September, with broader organisational changes expected to result in a reduction of around 1,000 roles by the middle of next year.”
Crucially, many cuts in the sector relate to the premium end of services such as wealth management, as much as they do bank branches and call centres. According to a report last month, HSBC plans to axe as many as 70 per cent of financial advisers within its wealth management arm.
This presents a key test for financial services: can they keep charging premium fees to top clients without offering the same level of human-led service? Will clients pay through the nose for AI-led advisory services when, with a bit of training, they could get ninety percent of the job done with a £20 Claude subscription? Banks seem to think so.