Closer ties to the EU will do nothing to bring down energy costs

Andy Burnham and Ursula von der Leyen engaging in discussion at an event

Prime Minister Andy Burnham’s proposed UK-EU emissions trading scheme linkage will drive up energy costs rather than lower them. Instead, the government should abolish domestic green levies to make life more affordable for Britons, says Joseph Dinnage

For British politics, this week may prove the most important of the decade. 

On Friday, Andy Burnham will travel to Brussels for the UK-EU Summit. It is from this meeting that he will set in motion his ‘reset’ with the European Union, a thinly veiled plan to rejoin the bloc by stealth. This is an organisation that just over ten years ago, the British people voted to leave.

Last night, the Prime Minister made his intentions clear. Speaking at the Lord Mayor’s banquet, everyman Burnham declared in white tie that “the Brexit we were given has not worked. We have lost more than we have gained”. The time has come apparently to seriously discuss our “long-term relationship” with Brussels. It should be added that Burnham did qualify that his negotiations with the EU will not entail a return to the single market, the customs union, or freedom of movement.

If you believe that, then I’ve got a bridge to sell you.

Stay in the know

Three daily briefings with the key market moves and top business and political stories.

SUBSCRIBE HERE

Burnham, who only a few years ago backed a second referendum on the EU, will use the upcoming Summit to sign new agreements on food, energy and youth mobility. All three deserve articles in themselves, but his proposal for energy is particularly deranged.

The government claims that linking our and the EU’s emissions trading schemes (ETS) will save British exporters £800m. This is because they will not have to pay into the EU Carbon Border Adjustment Mechanism (CBAM) scheme. The claim is based on a 2024 Frontier Economics report that justified UK-EU ETS linkage on the basis that lower carbon prices in the UK ETS could lead to British businesses paying £0.2–0.8bn into the EU budget as CBAM between 2026 and 2030.

Burnham’s deal would make life more expensive

This is a fiction, and the report contradicts its own argument by showing the economy taking a £3.5-8bn hit from avoidable carbon taxes. The grim reality is that under Burnham’s proposed deal, life would become even more expensive. We at the Prosperity Institute have calculated that if UK-EU ETS linkage went ahead, it would raise British carbon prices towards EU levels, with prices increasing by around 32 per cent.

If Burnham genuinely wants to lower energy costs, he will put ideology to one side and confront the green levies raising prices.

Our research recommends scrapping the Climate Change Levy, Carbon Price Support, UK ETS and the proposed UK CBAM. This would make a tremendous difference to the lives of ordinary Britons. 

If the government toughened up and abolished these measures, energy users would see their bills cut by £7.2bn a year. This is equivalent to around £250 per household, including around £60 directly off household energy bills, at a gross cost of £4.2bn to the Exchequer and resulting in a long-run GDP boost of up to £7.4bn.

Turning to Brussels would be a cowardly, undemocratic and ultimately ineffective abdication of sovereignty

It might offend Net Zero zealots like Miatta Fahnbulleh, but the truth is that government-imposed taxes designed to force consumers to adopt renewable energy have made life much more expensive. Rejoining the EU is often modelled by the Left as a silver bullet for solving Britain’s problems, but as our latest research demonstrates, our chronic issues have nothing to do with Brexit.

Getting consumer energy prices down requires the same domestic political will as it does to boost economic growth or reduce migration. Turning to Brussels would be a cowardly, undemocratic and ultimately ineffective abdication of sovereignty. Burnham has pledged to give Britons breathing space and said that he will not be squeamish about fixing Britain’s problems. If he is a man of his word, he will start by taking bold decisions, here at home, to make life more affordable for British citizens.

Joseph Dinnage is senior press officer at the Prosperity Institute

Original source Closer ties to the EU will do nothing to bring down energy costs

Back to home