Brexit: Rejoin and leave campaigns can’t win with yesterday’s arguments

(An anti brexit protester seen with his placard and a EU flag outside the house of parliament. -- Photo by Dinendra Haria/SOPA Images/LightRocket via Getty Images)

Brexit is back on the agenda, but research shows leave and rejoin campaigners will need new arguments to win over today’s voters, says Morgan Jones

Today, as you will likely be aware, the EU-UK summit will be taking place in. It’s the most tangible step so far in Andy Burnham’s re-opening of the conversation about rejoining the bloc. The Prime Minister’s clear language about the failures of Brexit indicates that this is likely to be a key theme over the coming years and indeed at the next general election. In response to this new push to rejoin, we have also seen the launch of new campaigns, “Stay Out” – more Tory aligned – and “Enough Official” – more Reform aligned – which will look to strengthen and re-affirm the leave case. Despite its triumph at the ballot box a decade ago, most polling now suggests that a plurality of Brits favour rejoining and a majority consider Brexit a mistake.

At Persuasion UK, we aim to get behind headline figures like this and test, as much as is possible, how they translate when mapped onto the messy processes of the real world. Testing opinion on Brexit is exactly the kind of thing that requires this approach, because so much of what people feel about being in or out of Europe was created through the process of the referendum and subsequent debates. As political scientists Sarah Hobolt and James Tilley have compellingly argued, Brexit created, rather than brought to the fore, the tribes of “leaver” and “remainer”. How will the toplines we’re currently seeing – where the success of Brexit is rated catastrophically low even by leave voters, and where demographics alone swing the population into a pro-EU position – be acted on by a live campaign? What issues can we expect to be most salient?

Voter exhaustion

The main beat “Stay Out” hit in their first press release was about the increased cost of membership of the EU. The figures at the heart of this – not unlike certain other numbers associated with the leave cause – are disputed, but our research clearly showed that budget contributions are an area of significant concern for the public, with hostile media on this sinking rejoin numbers by nine points amongst the sample shown them. Any suggestion that Britain might have to join the Euro is also a point of real difficulty. However, despite the centrality of immigration in “Enough Official”’s launch video, our research suggests free movement clearly no longer provides the attack line it did a decade ago. While immigration might have been at the core of the case Farage and others made about the EU in the 2010s, our testing suggests it would not be particularly potent at destabilising rejoin sympathies today, particularly given people’s deep frustrations with increased barriers to travel since Brexit.

One area of concern for rejoiners, which might be described as process rather than policy, is voter exhaustion. In our research, the longer you tell people a process of negotiating and rejoining will be, the less appealing it is. This chimed with things I found while writing a book on the People’s Vote campaign: the committed activists campaigning for a new referendum often struggled to internalise the fact that even if many people basically agreed with them, their primary preference was to simply have the whole thing over and done with.

Stay in the know

Three daily briefings with the key market moves and top business and political stories.

SUBSCRIBE HERE

A lot has changed in ten years. Both sides of the issue will have to learn to play new games and make new arguments. Arguably this is even more true for the leave side, simply because arguments which were successful beforehand are naturally more tempting than those which failed you. But any campaign re-heating past points will quickly find that yesterday’s arguments don’t necessarily map onto today’s political terrain.

Morgan Jones is the deputy director of Persuasion UK and the author of “No Second Chances: The inside story of the campaign for a second EU referendum

Original source Brexit: Rejoin and leave campaigns can’t win with yesterday’s arguments

Back to home