Alan Milburn has issued a wake-up call on NEETs, but Labour’s not listening

Job Centre Plus sign on a brick building, reflecting trees and sky, representing UK employment services.

Alan Milburn has warned that Labour’s own policies on tax and regulation are contributing to the NEETs crisis, but the government’s response is to ignore everything he said about this assault on business, says Helen Whately

Business needs a break, and even Labour’s own Alan Milburn agrees. His final report on young people and work, published yesterday, should be a wake-up call for ministers, because it lays bare the damage this government has done to young people’s prospects.

Just look at what employers have been hit with: National Insurance up; inflation-busting rises in minimum wage costs; business rates up. And on top of it all, the Employment Rights Act, with job-killing policies on page after page. Milburn’s review confirms that more than a third of employers now plan to hire fewer permanent staff as a result. Young people’s prospects have gone up in smoke, and Labour has fiddled while Rome burned.

Milburn understands this. “There is nothing progressive about pricing young people out of work,” he writes, and he is right. He goes further, warning that government “cannot be indifferent to the cumulative effect of the costs and obligations it places on the decision to hire.” Yet indifference is exactly what we’ve had, Budget after Budget.

Flooded with new regulation

He also warns that the youth labour market must not be “flooded with more new regulation.” Ministers should pin that line above every desk in Whitehall.

Stay in the know

Three daily briefings with the key market moves and top business and political stories.

SUBSCRIBE HERE

So how has the government responded? By looking the other way. Responding in Parliament, the welfare secretary simply ignored every line in the report that points to their assault on business. Instead, he only signed the government up to the recommendations that promise more spending.

None of this should surprise anyone. It feels like a lifetime since Milburn’s interim report back in May, and since then we’ve had a new Prime Minister and a new Chancellor delivering a Budget. But one thing hasn’t changed: the same Labour backbenchers who won’t stomach the tough choices needed to bring the welfare bill down. They are already lining up to warn ministers off welfare savings. Some have taken to X, others have even written to the Prime Minister directly indicating they would oppose benefit reform. 

Conservatives have been clear from the start. We need businesses hiring and young people back into work. That’s why we would halve employer National Insurance for under-25s, worth £1,500 a year to a business employing a young person on the National Living Wage. We would also roll back the job-destroying measures in the Employment Rights Act and deliver Get to Work, a plan for young people without a strong work record who are claiming Universal Credit. Instead of sitting at home losing confidence, they would be expected to show up every day, whether at the jobcentre or on work experience, in return for their Universal Credit. That’s tough love, but the alternative is a generation watching their skills disappear and their detachment grow.

And we would deliver £36bn of welfare savings, so we can cut taxes and let business get on with what it does best, employing people and giving them the chance to build a life of their own.

Where Milburn gets it right, we’ll back him.

The question is whether Labour has the courage to do the same. 

Helen Whately is shadow secretary of state for work and pensions

Original source Alan Milburn has issued a wake-up call on NEETs, but Labour’s not listening

Back to home