
AI has made it easier than ever to submit complaints, FOIs and other previously friction-bound tasks. Paul Ormerod considers how departments can wade through this new administrative slop
Revolutionary technologies always have unexpected side effects. Generative AI is certainly no exception.
The release of ChatGPT just over four years ago marked the beginning of what we can think of as the truly modern AI era.
In many ways it is hard to imagine that this was only in 2022. No one anticipated at the time that generative AI would now be establishing important new results in maths. OpenAI has announced hundreds of proofs in the past few months, for example.
This has sparked intense debate amongst mathematicians. The maths community has long accepted computer-assisted proofs which no human can check by hand, such as the famous 1976 result on the so-called Four Colour Theorem.
Stay in the know
Three daily briefings with the key market moves and top business and political stories.
SUBSCRIBE HEREThe argument is more about whether the proof advances human understanding. A massive, opaque document tells mathematicians that a statement is true, but not why it is true. Still, some exceptionally hard problems do seem to have been solved.
A surge of FOIs
It is a long way from the esoteric world of pure maths to the desks of Whitehall and local councils. But here, too, generative AI has had unanticipated effects.
The cabinet secretary Antonia Romeo warned in the past week that a “surge of automated, high-volume citizen demand is hitting operational desks today” at an unprecedented “scale and pace”. AI agents are now submitting consultation responses on behalf of their users and drafting complex freedom of information (FOI) requests at the touch of a button.
New AI tools have been introduced in the civil service at least to try to deal with these tsunamis. They are explicitly designed to reduce the amount of time which humans need to spend on the submissions and complaints.
But getting into an arms race with generative AI does not really feel like a permanent solution to the problem.
It is easier to think of potential solutions in two other, separate but related areas where AI is having a big impact.
Trade unions, for example, are often in competition with others for members. The new threat to them is that the individual members themselves are discovering the generative AI can handle many of the issues which they have. The annual membership fee may no longer seem such good value.
The general secretary of the Prospect union has openly attacked this new trend. Only last month Mike Clancy warned that “sycophantic” AI chatbots have led to a surge in claims from angry staff who wrongly believe they have a case for minor workplace grievances. Unions, he said, were seeing a “spike in nonsense claims”.
In the same way, HR departments are being overwhelmed by complaints. Neil Morrison, the head of HR at Severn Trent, said those coming in are “quoting case law which is often not applicable”. But they are lengthy and each one has to be given a proper response.
It is possible that this recent surge will fade away as people observe that demands for compensation are not succeeding in the way they imagined. Yet even if the reaction is entirely rational and staff do learn from the experience of others, this can take a long time.
A techy problem needs a human response
The way forward lies with the HR departments readjusting their priorities. Instead of reacting to grievances, they should be in the forefront of efforts to generate a corporate culture in which complaints simply become less part of the staff ethos.
Social network research repeatedly shows that people are much more willing to accept unfavourable outcomes, for example, if they perceive the process to be fair. AI changes the cost of complaining. It does not change human perceptions of fairness.
The way to deal with the problems created by AI is not by trying to have better technology, but to have better human responses.
Paul Ormerod is an honorary professor at the Alliance Business School at the University of Manchester. You can follow him on Instagram @profpaulormerod