A dynamic country would not have lost its mind over Poundland collapse

Exterior view of a Poundland store entrance with its teal blue signage and glass doors

Allow me to be blunt: a country benefiting from a healthy economy would not have lost its mind over the possible disappearance of a discount retail chain.

I don’t mean to be heartless towards those whose jobs are at risk, but a dispassionate view of recent events would find it remarkable that the possible collapse of Poundland found its way on the Prime Minister’s desk.

In a healthy economy – with a dynamic labour market, robust consumer confidence and broad-based private sector investment – the jobs lost at one retailer would be absorbed by another. Creative destruction would play out.

Instead, the prospect of taking Poundland into public ownership was raised in parliament.

I mention all this because it serves as important context in understanding the recommendations of Alan Milburn in his review into youth unemployment. In fact it serves as important context in understanding why that review was commissioned in the first place.

Stay in the know

Three daily briefings with the key market moves and top business and political stories.

SUBSCRIBE HERE

As Milburn makes clear, many reasons exist for the surge in youth unemployment. You could argue there are 981,000 reasons, given that everyone is different. However, amid the calls for personalised, one-to-one support for every NEET, policy-makers need to consider the wider conditions at play.

Undeniably, the post-pandemic spike in claims for Personal Independence Payments and the health element of Universal Credit must be addressed. I know someone who worked as a PIP assessor; she was paid extremely well for signing off almost every claimant after an online assessment in which almost everyone read from a script. Milburn is right to call for a crackdown on private clinics offering ADHD diagnosis, but it’s time to question whether that condition should even lead to welfare payments at all.

How can ministers be surprised by any of this?

Another dynamic that cannot be ignored and which, to his credit, Milburn pays some attention to, is the crippling increase in employment costs.

I know I’ve banged this drum before but if the government decides to make it £4,000 more expensive to hire someone on the minimum wage, it really should not be surprised by a decline in entry level jobs. And when the government adds huge risk and legal complexity onto employers through new employment rights laws, they should not be surprised when employers cool on the idea of hiring new staff.

Alan Milburn – a Blairite if he’s anything – has proposed a Blairite feast of new legal rights, charters, and guarantees. The government will lap it up when they should instead look back in horror at the mess they’ve made of our labour market.

Original source A dynamic country would not have lost its mind over Poundland collapse

Back to home